Bank of America: Claiming an AI bubble over OpenAI's money situation is a “lazy/cherry-picked argument”
Bank of America analyst Vivek Arya is throwing down the gauntlet: there’s one bear case against AI stocks he really doesn’t like.
“The common argument that ‘AI stocks must be overvalued because OpenAI cannot justify $1.4 trillion of long-term commitments’ is a lazy/cherry-picked argument in our view,” he wrote in a note to clients on Monday, in which the analyst reiterated his confidence in his favorite data center and semi stocks.
He added:
“While we agree OpenAI’s plans are very ambitious, none of that spending has yet been put in place and will be gated by practical constraints such as access to power and data center space. The majority of AI spending is being done by profitable, public hyperscalers for whom upgrading infrastructure is mission-critical (upgrade to accelerated from traditional CPU-computing) and defensive (e.g. Google’s $92bn capex ‘defends’ a $200bn+ search leadership by providing Gemini-chatbot driven results to all customers who might otherwise defect to ChatGPT, Perplexity or other search engines.) Meanwhile private AI companies are making rapid strides attracting business customers (1mn+ by OpenAI, 300K+ by Anthropic) which will continue to put pressure on public software and infrastructure-as-a service vendors to raise AI investments.”
On the one hand, yes, I concur: while ChatGPT may have been what brought the AI boom into public consciousness, it’s not the alpha and omega of the movement. The continued push from the publicly traded, immensely profitable tech companies that lead the S&P 500 is probably the more important factor behind the mile-deep, inch-wide AI spending boom in the here and now.
On the other hand, OpenAI’s spending commitments have driven big valuation bumps for Amazon, Broadcom, AMD, and Oracle in just the past two months. In other words, those stocks have priced in that demand being real and realized. To the extent it isn’t, or can’t be, well then some overvaluation worries would be somewhat justified.
Reports that OpenAI is moving toward an IPO, however, would offer some enhanced confidence that it’ll be able to get its hands on the cash necessary to follow through on these pledges.